Article 2
This Decision is addressed to:
1. Exxon Corporation 5959 Las Calinas Boulevard Irving Texas USA
2. Mobil Corporation 3225 Gallows Road Fairfax Virginia USA
Done at Brussels, 29 September 1999.
For the Commission
Mario Monti
Member of the Commission
(1) OJ L 395, 30.12.1989, p. 1; corrected version published in OJ L 257, 21.9.1990, p. 13.
(2) OJ L 180, 9.7.1997, p. 1.
(3) OJ C 87, 7.4.2004.
(4) Case IV/M.727, BP/Mobil of 7 August 1996 (OJ C 381, 17.12.1996, p. 8). The activities of the joint venture do not include marine and aviation lubricants.
(5) Turnover calculated in accordance with Article 5(1) of the Merger Regulation and the Commission notice on the calculation of turnover (OJ C 66, 2.3.1998, p. 25). To the extent that figures include turnover for the period before 1 January 1999, they are calculated on the basis of average ecu exchange rates and translated into euro on a one-for-one basis.
(6) Parts of this text have been edited to ensure that confidential information is not disclosed; those parts are enclosed in square brackets and marked with an asterisk.
(7) See Commission decision in Case IV/M.1200, Arco/Union Texas (OJ C 16, 21.1.1999, p. 8) Commission decision in Case IV/M.88, Elf Enterprise (OJ C 203, 2.8.1991) and Commission decision in Case IV/M.85, Elf Occidental (OJ C 160, 20.6.1991).
(8) Prices in the crude oil trade markets may be significantly influenced by mere announcements following an OPEC meeting.
(9) OJ L 204, 21.7.1998, p. 1.
(10) The coal and steel aspects of the case have been dealt with by the Commission in Case IV/ECSC.1252, RAG/Saarbergwerke. The German decision is summarised in the BKartA's biannual working report and its press release of 4 February 1998.
(11) It is not necessary for the purpose of this case to decide whether there is a separate LCV and HCV gas market in the Netherlands, as the outcome of the case would not be materially different.
(12) [...]*
(13) [...]*
(14) [...]*
(15) [...]*
(16) [...]*
(17) [...]*
(18) [...]*
(19) Joined Cases C-68/94 and C-30/95 France and Others v Commission (1998) ECR I-1375.
(20) Judgment of 25 March 1999 in Case T-102/96 Gencor v Commission (not yet reported).
(21) DEUDAN (pipeline bringing Danish gas to Germany): [...]* %, BEB [...]* %; NETRA (pipeline bringing Norwegian gas to North Germany): BEB [...]* %, Ruhrgas [...]* %; Salzwedel-Berlin (extension of NETRA to Berlin): BEB [...]* %, Ruhrgas [...]* %, VNG [...]* %; NETG (pipeline bringing Dutch LCV gas to Germany): Ruhrgas [...]* %, Thyssengas [...]* %; METG (pipeline bringing Dutch HCV gas to Germany): Ruhrgas [...]* %, Exxon and Shell each [...]* %; SETG (extension of METG): Ruhrgas [...]* %, Exxon and Shell each [...]* % (the NETG-METG-SETG pipelines are extensions of one another); EVG (pipeline link in Central Germany): Ruhrgas [...]* %, VNG [...]* %.
(22) [...]* - Annex 49.21 (italics added). Also [...]* - Annex 49.26.
(23) Table 3.13 in "Competition and Liberalisation in European Gas Markets - A Diversity of Models", Jonathan P. Stern, Royal Institute of International Affairs, 1998.
(24) Bresnahan, T.F. and Salop, S.C., "Quantifying the competitive effects of joint ventures", International Journal of Industrial Organisation, vol. 4 (1986) pp. 155-175.
(25) API stands for American Petroleum Institute and regroups oil companies; ACEA stands for association des constructeurs européens d'automobile and ATIEL stands for association technique de l'industrie européennes des lubrifiants. Their respective roles are further explained in this section.
(26) Group II is not currently used in the EEA.
(27) As confirmed by the competitors, all DI manufacturers have generic approvals in Exxon, Mobil and Shell base oils that are available for base oil customers.
(28) Exceptions exist for group III and IV base oils.
(29) As described in documents such as "API 1509" and "Atiel code of practice".
(30) Case IV/M.1137, Exxon/Shell of 25 May 1998.
(31) [...]*
(32) [...]*
(33) [...]*
(34) [...]*
(35) [...]*
(36) [...]*
(37) [...]*
(38) [...]*
(39) [...]*
(40) BP/Mobil have spent approximately USD [...]* million in order to obtain interchangeability between its (then) [...]* European refineries.
(41) [...]*
(42) [...]*.
(43) [...]*
(44) [...]*
(45) [...]*
(46) Toll blending refers to the blending of lubricants under the brand of and according to the specifications of a lubricant blender (who may be without production capacity in that region).
(47) [...]*.
(48) [...]*.
(49) [...]*.
(50) [...]*.
(51) [...]*.
(52) [...]*.
(53) [...]*.
(54) [...]*.
(55) [...]*.
(56) [...]*.
(57) [...]*.
(58) [...]*.
(59) Case T-102/96, Gencor v Commission, not yet published.
(60) Since no industry data on average pump prices on motorways are available, Exxon pump prices on motorways are taken as a proxy of the industry average pump prices. Similarly, the parties could not isolate data concerning solely toll motorways. The Commission therefore took data covering all motorways as a proxy for toll motorways.
(61) Account should also be taken of the fact that Total has recently acquired Fina which has the poorest performance in terms of throughput per site.
(62) [...]*.
(63) On the basis of the market shares of the main eastern German competitors 1998 provided by the parties.
(64) [...]*.
(65) [...]*.
(66) Study Bayerische Landeskartellbehörde 1998.
(67) [...]*.
(68) Competition in the supply of petrol in the United Kingdom - A report by the Office of Fair Trading: May 1998.
(69) See footnote 68.
(70) Auxiliary power units, constant speed drivers, integrated drive generators and air turbine starters.
(71) Anecdotal evidence is that, in order to reduce possible safety risks, airlines use one and the same OEM-approved lubricant for stationary and airborne applications to ensure that a non-approved aero-derivative lubricant cannot be mistakenly used in an aircraft engine.
(72) In its decision of 6 July 1994 (Case IV/M.460 - Holdercim/Cedest) (OJ C 211, 2.8.1994), the Commission had stated that markets representing "less than one per cent of the Community consumption of the product" constitute an insubstantial part of the common market.
