Article 4
>TABLE>
Done at Brussels, 23 October 2003.
For the Commission
Mario Monti
Member of the Commission
(1) OJ 13, 21.2.1962, p. 204/62.
(2) OJ L 1, 4.1.2003, p. 1.
(3) OJ C 94, 23.4.2003, p. 3.
(4) OJ C 48, 24.2.2004.
(5) Commission Decision 1999/695/EC in Case No COMP/36.748 - REIMS II) (OJ L 275, 26.10.1999, p. 17).
(6) PPOs are corporations or government departments with the primary obligation of providing universal postal services across the national territory, often at a unitary price. They are also obliged to provide international postal services passing international mail to PPOs in other countries for distribution abroad and delivering incoming international mail. In the context of the notified Agreement, PPO refers to both public and private postal operators which are subject to a universal delivery service obligation.
(7) See Article 2 of the 1999 Exemption Decision, op. cit.
(8) OJ C 195, 11.7.2001, p. 11.
(9) Swiss Post is not a notifying party since it has not signed the notification to the Commission.
(10) OJ L 15, 21.1.1998, p. 14.
(11) OJ L 176, 5.7.2002, p. 21.
(12) The Universal Postal Convention, agreed to and signed by governments at the UPU Congress, concerns the formation of a single postal territory, freedom of transit, standardisation of postage rates, the institution of arbitration proceedings and the establishment of terminal dues.
(13) The UPU was founded in 1874 and forms the framework for postal relations between its members. The UPU is an organisation of governments and was recognised as a special agency of the United Nations in 1947.
(14) See recital 9 of the 1999 Exemption Decision.
(15) The CEPT was a restricted subgroup of the UPU which, up to 1992, brought together both the regulators and the operators of the European postal and telecommunication authorities. In September 1992, a major reform of the CEPT was undertaken and the CEPT adopted a new constitution which reserved membership to regulatory authorities. The operators created their own organisation, PostEurope.
(16) The CEPT system took account of total weight and number of items with payment based on a rate per item and a rate per kilogram. It recognised that the composition of mail in one direction may well differ from the composition in the other.
(17) See, for example, recital 10 of the 1999 Exemption Decision. See also the judgment of the Court of Justice in Joined Cases C-147/97 and C-148/97, Deutsche Post AG v GZS Gesellschaft für Zahlungssysteme mbH (GZS) and Deutsche Post AG v Citicorp Kartenservice GmbH, [2000] ECR 1-825, paragraph 54.
(18) Article 48(2) of the 1999 UPU Convention fixes a ceiling of 60 % of the charge for a 20 gram letter in the domestic service.
(19) A brief explanation of the REIMS I Agreement and a detailed description of the REIMS II Agreement, as notified to the Commission in 1997, are set out in recitals 12 to 43 of the 1999 Exemption Decision.
(20) In view of the discounts that they will grant until the end of 2004 (see footnote 22 below), Deutsche Post AG and Poste Italiane SpA would only reach the full 80 % level in 2005.
(21) Paragraph 3(4) of Annex 4 to the REIMS II Agreement as amended by Article 3(3) of the fourth Supplementary Agreement.
(22) Deutsche Post AG continues to grant the discount agreed in the third Supplementary Agreement until 31 December 2004. Poste Italiane SpA has also agreed to give a discount until that date: paragraphs 9 and 10 of Annex 4 to the REIMS II Agreement, as amended by the fourth Supplementary Agreement.
(23) Article 11(4) to (7) of the REIMS II Agreement, as amended by Article 2(2) of the fourth Supplementary Agreement.
(24) See section 4.5.
(25) Bags containing bulk mail for one addressee.
(26) The fifth Supplementary Agreement amends the transitional period and the terminal dues to be applied. See section 4.5.
(27) The "latest arrival time" is the latest acceptable time of touchdown, permitting delivery of airmail items the next working day.
(28) The International Post Corporation is a company co-owned by a number of PPOs including, for Europe, all the REIMS II Parties plus the PPOs of the Netherlands, Cyprus and Norway and, outside Europe, the PPOs of the USA, Australia and Canada. The IPC provides administrative and practical services to the REIMS II Parties. The UNEX quality-of-service measurement system - which serves as the basis for the REIMS II quality targets and determines penalties - is operated by the IPC.
(29) For example, if the quality-of-service target provides that 90 % of incoming cross-border mail must be delivered the next day, and that the actual result is that only 87 % of the mail is delivered within this time, then only 97 % of the target is reached (87 is 97 % of 90). Thus, the loss of quality is 3 %. Since this figure is within the 90 % to 100 % range, a penalty of 11/2 % for each percentage point accrues. The penalty is thus 3 × 11/2 % = 41/2 % of terminal dues payable. This means that the delivering PPO concerned is allowed to charge only 951/2 % (100 %-41/2 %) of the full terminal dues to which it would otherwise be entitled. In 1998 when terminal dues for Level 1 amounted to 55 % of domestic rates, the PPO would thus receive terminal dues amounting to 521/2 % of domestic rates (namely 951/2 % of 55 %).
(30) Article 2(11) of the REIMS II Agreement.
(31) This is the interpretation of this clause that the Parties have given in the course of the Commission's investigation.
(32) See Article 2(1)(b) of the 1999 Exemption Decision which also stated that: "In order to facilitate this access, the Parties must relax domestic conditions for other Parties where those rules are not justified and could in practice bar other Parties from access to the domestic rates or (where it is not in their power to do so) they must use their best efforts vis-à-vis the relevant national authorities to remove those rules".
(33) See Article 2(2)(a) of the 1999 Exemption Decision.
(34) The cost-to-revenue ratio indicates the ratio - expressed as a percentage - between the average cost of delivering one incoming cross-border mail item and the standard tariff for the corresponding domestic mail item.
(35) Article 2(2)(b) of the 1999 Exemption Decision obliges the Parties to provide annual reports on several issues including information on the implementation of Level 3 access.
(36) Article 7(1) of the Postal Directive.
(37) Article 9 of the REIMS II Agreement as notified on 18 June 2001.
(38) See section 9.4 on elimination of competition.
(39) The Agreement has not been signed yet by La Poste/De Post Belgium, Royal Mail UK and An Post Ireland. These Parties, however, are still signatories of the REIMS II Agreement as amended by the fourth Supplementary Agreement, any implementation of which is not covered by the exemption granted in this Decision.
(40) With the exception of Royal Mail Group plc and An Post.
(41) International direct mail (IDM) is the name the Parties have given to this cross-border mail product.
(42) The renotified REIMS II Agreement refers to Articles 25 and 49 of the UPU Convention signed in 1994. The fifth Supplementary Agreement refers to the UPU Convention signed in 1999. In the 1999 UPU Convention, ex-Article 25 is Article 43.
(43) See section 4.3.8.
(44) This figure is based on the analysis of the data on incoming and outgoing cross-border mail volumes provided by the Parties in their answers to the Commission's formal request for information of 6 August 2001.
(45) See Commission Decision 2001/892/EC in Case COMP/C-1/36.915 - Deutsche Post AG - Interception of cross-border mail (OJ L 331, 15.12.2001, p. 40) (Deutsche Post II), recitals 84 to 87.
(46) See for example, Commission decisions in Case No M.102, TNT v Canada Post, DBP Postdienst, La Poste, PTT Post and Sweden Post; Case IV/M.787, PTT Post v TNT-GD Net; Case No IV/M.843, PTT Post v TNT/GD Express Worldwide; Case IV/M.1168, Deutsche Post v DHL. See also recital 18 of the Postal Directive.
(47) See the decision in Deutsche Post II, recitals 84 to 87.
(48) See footnote 3.
(49) See recital 30.
(50) See recital 29.
(51) Article 2(11) of the REIMS II Agreement.
(52) Source: Parties' answers to Commission's formal request for information of 6 August 2001.
(53) See recital 65 of the 1999 Exemption Decision.
(54) See decison in Deutsche Post II, recital 179.
(55) See recital 69 of the 1999 Exemption Decision.
(56) See the table in Annex I.
(57) Source: UNEX official end-to-end results, Europe.
(58) See the Annex to the Postal Directive.
(59) The fact that REIMS contributed to the improvement of the quality of service in cross-border mail is specifically acknowledged in the "Study on the Impact of Certain Aspects of the Application of the Directive 97/67/EC on the Postal Sector" conducted by Omega Partners for the Commission in August 2001.
(60) See Annex I to this Decision.
(61) The target is slightly lower (80 %) for Greece, Iceland, Portugal and Spain.
(62) See section 4.4.
(63) It is possible that increases in tariffs are decided by the national regulators on the basis of different circumstances than increases in terminal dues. Recital 120 is therefore valid also in these particular circumstances since such increases of tariffs are not causally linked to the increases of terminal dues.
(64) See recital 80 of the 1999 Exemption Decision.
(65) Third-party access to Level 3 rates also necessitates access for third parties to the IPC database in which all the tariffs and conditions relevant for Level 3 access are made available. See recital 48.
(66) See recitals 86 and 88 of the 1999 Exemption Decision.
(67) The relevant data are gathered from the Parties' answers to the Commission's request for information, which were received on 24 September 2001.
(68) Weighted average is obtained by multiplying the cost-to-revenue ratio of each Party by a weighting factor, which is obtained on the basis of the volumes of incoming cross-border mail processed, and then calculating the average value.
(69) See section 4.5.
(70) Article 11(4) to (7) of the REIMS II Agreement as amended by Article 2(2) of the fourth Supplementary Agreement.
(71) Article 9 of the REIMS II Agreement as amended by the fourth Supplementary Agreement.
(72) The only exception is Sweden where alternative providers of delivery services are being used.
(73) See Commission Decision 83/390/EEC in Case No IV/30.437 Rockwell v Iveco (OJ L 224, 17.8.1983, p. 19); judgment of the Court of Justice in Case C-75/84 Metro SB-Grossmärkte v Commission [1986] ECR 3021, paragraphs 34 to 46; Commission Decision 94/29/EC in Case No IV/29.420 Grundig's EC distribution system (OJ L 20, 25.1.1994, p. 15) recitals 39, 40 and 41.
(74) See section 4.5.
(75) The cost data in question are gathered from the answers to the Commission's request for information of 6 August 2001 and make reference to Parties' costs for the delivery of incoming cross-border mail in 2000.
(76) It has been specified by the Parties that the cost data submitted to the Commission do not include any profit margin.
(77) Article 2(6) of the REIMS II Agreement obliges the Parties to grant such access to other Parties.
