← Gesamte Rechtsvorschrift

Art. 4 ·

EU-Recht · · Quelle: EUR-Lex · Nicht mehr in Kraft

In EUR-Lex öffnen
Schriftgröße: 100 %

Article 4

This decision is addressed to the Federal Republic of Germany.

Done at Brussels, 8 July 1999.

For the Commission

Monika Wulf-Mathies

Member of the Commission

(1) OJ C 140, 5.5.1998, p. 9.

(2) OJ L 124, 5.5.1989, p. 16.

(3) See footnote 1.

(4) Sections 36 to 46 of the North Rhine-Westphalian law on savings banks (Gesetz über die Sparkassen sowie über die Girozentrale und Sparkassen- und Giroverbände).

(5) At 31 December 1991 55,6 % of WestLB group's long-term claims on customers were loans to public institutions (Annual Report 1991, p. 72). At 31 December 1997 such loans had accounted for 32,9 % of WestLB group's total claims on customers (Annual Report 1997, p. 74).

(6) Section 4(2) of the Decree regulating the business activities of savings banks in North Rhine-Westphalia (Verordnung zur Regelung des Geschäftsrechts und des Betriebes der Sparkassen in Nordrhein-Westfalen).

(7) Wohnungsbauförderungsgesetz, in the version published on 30 September 1979 (Official Gazette of North Rhine-Westphalia, p. 630).

(8) OJ L 386, 30.12.1989, p. 14.

(9) The capital requirements must be met by credit institutions on a consolidated, a subconsolidated and an unconsolidated basis.

(10) The term "risk-adjusted assets" is used below to describe all risk-bearing and risk-adjusted items.

(11) In fact, the new capital requirements should already have entered into force on 1 January 1993 but were implemented late in Germany.

(12) However, this figure was based on a definition of own funds that was narrower than the one set out in the Own Funds Directive.

(13) OJ L 29, 5.2.1993, p. 1.

(14) It should, however, be pointed out that not only the thresholds were changed but also the definitions of "own funds" and of "risk-adjusted assets".

(15) OJ L 386, 30. 12. 1989, p. 1.

(16) Deutsche Bundesbank, monthly report, May 1993, p. 49.

(17) See, for example, Document 11/2329 of the parliament of North Rhine-Westphalia.

(18) Gesetz zur Regelung der Wohnungsbauförderung of 18 December 1991 (Official Gazette of the Land of North Rhine-Westphalia, No 61 of 30 December 1991, p. 561).

(19) According to the German Government, the expression "act in money's worth" used there is in fact imprecise and was clarified later.

(20) Section 13 of the law concerning the asset transfer states that the housing promotion division must carry out its tasks in a manner that is neutral in its effect on competition (führt ihre Aufgaben wettbewerbsneutral durch). The actual measures to be taken to this end are laid down in an agreement between WestLB and the Land authorities.

(21) This calculation leaves out of account the risk-bearing off-balance-sheet transactions.

(22) It should be borne in mind that, under the new rules, not only the ratios changed but also the definitions of "own funds" and "risk-adjusted assets".

(23) According to a study submitted by the German Government on the remuneration paid by WestLB, the corporation tax rate was 46 % until 1993 and 42 % thereafter. To this must be added a solidarity surcharge of 3,75 % in 1992, 0 % in 1993 and 7,5 % thereafter.

(24) For the sake of clarity, where the amount on which the remuneration is to be paid is discussed, reference is always made to the situation at the end of 1993, i,e. the split between DEM 1500 million (EUR 770 million) and DEM 2500 million (EUR 1280 million), irrespective of the fact that the division between the capital tied up in Wfa business and the amount available for WestLB changes.

(25) The 0,6 % rate was laid down in a protocol note to the covering agreement dated 11 November 1993.

(26) The German Government has explained that there was an agreement between the owners that such recovery payments should be made but that there was no corresponding legal obligation on WestLB.

(27) The following features are described: country of issue and issuer, treatment of the instrument by banking regulators, typical maturity, treatment in the event of bankruptcy/liquidation and for loss absorption, whether it is callable, whether it is possible to defer interest/dividend payments and whether a cumulative deferral is possible.

(28) Wfa's capital is compared in one version only to profit participation certificates and perpetual preferred stock and in another to all three instruments

(29) Data from the American and British markets were used for perpetual preferred shares, as these instruments are not available in Germany.

(30) The study uses the capital asset pricing model to calculate these rates. This model starts with a risk-free interest rate (here that of German Government bonds with a remaining period to maturity of 10 years, i.e. 8,26 % at the end of 1991) and adds to this a risk premium for equity which is derived from historical market data (here 3,0 % to 4,0 %); this figure is adjusted by a factor reflecting the systematic risk of the respective enterprises in comparison with the total market (here 0,77 %, derived from the market performance of two German banks, BHF-Bank and IKB).

(31) This is based on the rate of 0,6 %, a corporation tax rate of 46 % until 1993 and 42 % thereafter, plus a solidarity surcharge rate of 3,75 % in 1992, 0 % in 1993 and 7,5 % thereafter.

(32) This is based, firstly, on the fact that the special reserve was accepted by BAKred only on 30 December 1992, resulting in a figure for usable capital (for calculation purposes) of only DEM [...] (EUR [...]), and, secondly, on the payment in 1992 by WestLB of DEM [...] (EUR [...]) for future pension entitlements of Wfa staff, which is taken as remuneration paid by WestLB to the Land in that year.

(33) See, for example, Cases C-303/88 Italy v Commission [1991] ECR I-1433 and C-305/89 Italy v Commission [1991] ECR I-1603.

(34) Commission communication to the Member States: Application of Articles 92 and 93 of the EEC Treaty and of Article 5 of Commission Directive 80/723/EEC to public undertakings in the manufacturing sector (OJ C 307, 13.11.1993, p. 3, point 11). While this communication deals explicitly with the manufacturing sector, the principle can undoubtedly be applied in the same way to all other sectors. As regards financial services, this has been confirmed by a number of Commission decisions, e.g. in the cases Crédits Lyonnais (OJ L 221, 8.8.1998, p. 28). and GAN (OJ L 78, 16.3.1998, p. 1).

(35) Public authorities' holdings in company capital - Commission Position (Bull. 9 - 1984, pp. 93-95).

(36) OJ C 307, 13.11.1993, p. 3, point 37.

(37) It cannot be said that investments are made only in profitable companies on the market. High-risk investments, e.g. in innovative or new technology companies, are quite common. However, in these cases too the investor invests his capital on the expectation that the start-up losses and the risks involved can subsequently be offset by high profits. Even in the case of such investments, the benchmark is the expected long-term return.

(38) This point is also stressed by the Commission's outside experts, who criticise the fact that the studies submitted by the German authorities omit any reference to the size of the transaction and compare the transfer to what are (in terms of size) marginal instruments. According to those experts, Wfa's capital should therefore be compared instead to original own funds instruments like non-voting shares.

(39) The outside study drawn up for it supports the Commission's view and comments on various individual assessments in the study submitted by the German Government. For example, it sheds a different light on the "coupon effect" by stating that, in the event of ongoing losses or liquidation, the whole capital and not only part of it would be lost. The study also points to two subjective elements of the study submitted by the German Government: market data are said to be used selectively and in some places are simply replaced by data from the authors' own experience, without this being stated explicitly.

(40) Of course, in reality the situation is much more complex because of off-balance-sheet items, different risk weightings of assets or zero-risk items etc. However, the principal reasoning holds.

(41) The situation does not change if one takes into account the possibility of raising additional own funds up to the same amount of original own funds (a factor of 25 instead of 12,5 for original own funds).

(42) In the decision to initiate the procedure laid down in Article 88(2) of the Treaty, the Commission provisionally indicated a rate of 7 % on the basis of information submitted at that time by WestLB.

(43) According to documents provided by the German Government, the corporation tax rate was 46 % in 1992, plus a solidarity surcharge of 3,75 %, i.e. 49,75 % in total. This gives net refinancing costs of 4,15 %. The overall tax rate fell to 46 % in 1993 and has stood at 49,5 % since 1994, giving net refinancing costs of 4,46 % and 4,17 % respectively. The 4,2 % rate is therefore justified not only for 1992 but also as an average.

(44) The same rate was used by the Commission in its decision on State aid for the French bank Crédit Lyonnais, where it stated that the relevant rate must be "the rate that the capital markets would have used in order to assess the return on their contribution. According to estimates made by a number of experts, including Crédit Lyonnais, the appropriate rate of return for capital invested in a bank is of the order of 12 %" (OJ L 308, 21.12.1995, p. 92, Section 6.3).

(45) It is worth pointing out that, in principle, investors primarily look at net returns when comparing investments.

(46) This assessment is borne out by the study by the Commission's outside experts, who asume a rate of between 12 % and 13 % after tax as a minimum remuneration for equity at the time of the transaction. They add that investors were likely at that time to have had higher expectations (by around 1 percentage point) because of the European convergence process.

(47) The study by the Commission's consultants provides an example of a loss-making bank in the United States which suffered from a serious capital shortage and put together a robust restructuring plan. In order to attract an investor, it had to grant a considerable one-off discount on the quoted share price. Certainly, the case is not directly comparable to the one at issue (and the discount applied only once, at the time of the injection), but it shows that, where large amounts of capital are urgently needed, an investor asks for a premium.

(48) The principle that non-voting shares should yield a preferential dividend above the normal level has been established by the Commission in past decisions (see, for example, the Commission's letter to Belgium dated 25 July 1984 regarding the firm Sidmar).

(49) The study by the Commission's outside experts stresses that a market economy investor would expect a premium to be paid for each of these special circumstances and proposes for all three aspects together a premium of 1 to 2 percentage points.

(50) This report was presented to the Ecofin Council on 23 November 1998 but has not been published. It can be obtained from the Competition Directorate-General of the Commission and can also be found on the Commission's website.