Article 2
The exemption set out in Article 1 of this Decision shall be subject to the following conditions:
Condition No 1: (Legal separation of BiB box and services operations - auditors)
The auditors who are required to certify on an annual basis that the marketing contribution activities of McCo. have been undertaken at arms' length to the activities of BiB Services Co. will interpret the term "arms' length" in accordance with the transfer pricing guidelines.
Condition No 2: (Information on the removal of subscription tie between BiB boxes and BSkyB services)
A. The BiB Parties will procure that retailers who sell digital interactive reception equipment with the benefit of marketing contributions and installers of such equipment are informed in writing that there is no requirement that a purchaser of such equipment should take out a subscription to any pay-television services and that services other than BSkyB's services will be available via the BiB box including those non-subscription services which are transmitted via digital satellite for reception on BiB boxes. The BiB Parties will further require that purchasers of equipment benefiting from marketing contributions are advised in writing at the point of sale that there is no such requirement and that services other than BSkyB's services will be available via the BiB box including those non-subscription services which are transmitted via digital satellite for reception on BiB boxes.
B. BSkyB will put in place written procedures, of which it will provide copies to the Commission, to ensure that all of its analogue customers, when offered a subscription to BSkyB's digital satellite services ("Sky Digital Subscription"), are informed clearly in writing (by notice approved in writing by the Commission) that there is no requirement for them to take out a Sky Digital Subscription in order to be eligible to purchase a BiB box and that services other than BSkyB's services will be available via the BiB box including those non-subscription services which are transmitted via digital satellite for reception on BiB boxes.
C. BSkyB will put in place written procedures, of which it will provide copies to the Commission, to ensure that its agents for the sale of Sky Digital Subscriptions who also sell BiB boxes are informed clearly in writing that there is no requirement on the purchaser to take out a Sky Digital Subscription in order to be eligible to purchase a BiB box and that services other than BSkyB's services will be available via the BiB box including those non-subscription services which are transmitted via digital satellite for reception on BiB boxes.
Condition No 3: (Availability of a clean feed)
Where movies and/or sports programming (but not advertising time paid for by parties other than BSkyB or BiB) on any of BSkyB's movies and/or sports channels includes on-screen representations directing the viewer to BiB's digital interactive television services and/or BSkyB's enhanced movies and/or sports television services, BSkyB will give distributors of such channels, on a non-discriminatory basis, an option either:
(i) where the distributor is also a distributor of BiB's digital interactive television services and/or BSkyB's enhanced movies and/or sports television services (as the case may be), to receive a signal for the channel(s) which include(s) the on-screen representation and interactive applications (authored in BSkyB's chosen technology) directing the viewer to such of BiB's digital interactive television services and/or BSkyB's enhanced movies and/or sports television services as the distributor is carrying, or
(ii) to receive a signal for the channel(s) such that the on-screen representations directing the viewer to such of BiB's digital interactive television services and/or BSkyB's enhanced movies and/or sports television services as the distributor is not carrying may not be viewed by means of, at the distributor's option, either:
(a) (where delivery of the channel is by satellite) a signal which includes the on-screen representations within a part of the signal which is transmitted separately from the main television picture; or
(b) (where delivery of the channel is by landline) a signal which does not include the on-screen representations or, at the distributor's option, includes them within a part of the signal which is transmitted separately from the main television picture(172); or
such other means as is agreed by the parties. This is subject in any such case to the distributor bearing any costs incurred in the development and ongoing provision of any such solution, including, where relevant, the costs relating to the installation, operation and maintenance of a landline and any related equipment necessary to provide the feed by landline.
Condition No 4: (Divestiture of cable)
A. BT shall not buy or seek any broadband cable television franchises in the United Kingdom beyond its existing holdings, and shall dispose of any such franchises acquired in the course of any other transaction. This undertaking shall however not restrict BT from providing broadcast services (should BT be permitted to do so in the future), broadband services or broadband interactive services (including for the avoidance of doubt in competition with the franchises in Westminster and Milton Keynes) over its own networks.
B. With effect from the date of this Decision (the "Exemption Decision") to divest itself of its broadband cable television franchises in Westminster and Milton Keynes (together "the Businesses") on the following basis:
(i) BT shall use its best efforts to arrange for the sale of the Businesses, at fair market value, within [...](173) months of the Exemption Decision;
(ii) BT shall maintain the Businesses in legally separate entities and shall operate them in a manner which enables it to maintain, as far as possible, their viability, marketability and value pending sale and final disposal;
(iii) prior to the sale of the Businesses, BT shall separately manage and hold separate the Businesses from the other businesses of BT in the United Kingdom Structural changes to the Businesses, until the date of such sale, shall not be undertaken by BT until after BT shall have informed the Commission of any such proposed change and the Commission shall not have explicitly opposed such proposed additional change in writing within two weeks of receiving BT's notice of change;
(iv) BT shall, as soon as reasonably practicable after receipt of the Commission's Decision, submit to the Commission a list of three nominations of accountancy firms, investment banks or similar undertakings. One such firm or bank or other body shall be appointed, subject to the approval of the Commission, as an independent expert. Such expert shall, if the Commission so requests, report to the Commission on whether or not BT is complying with subparagraph (iii).
C. If the Businesses have not been sold within the deadline set out in subparagraph B(i), BT shall appoint, subject to the approval of the Commission, a trustee in relation to the Businesses (such trustee may be the expert appointed in accordance with subparagraph B(iv) above). The terms of appointment shall be such that the trustee shall use his best efforts to sell the Businesses at fair market value within [...](174) months of the Exemption Decision or on such other terms as may be agreed between BT and the Commission.
D. If the trustee has not sold the Businesses in accordance with paragraph C, the trustee shall be obliged to sell the Businesses for the best possible price they are reasonably able to obtain within [...](175) months of the Exemption Decision. (The remaining terms and conditions of the trustee's appointment shall continue to apply.)
E. BT or, where relevant, the trustee shall notify the Commission in writing of the identity of the proposed purchaser of the Business. If, within ten working days of receipt of such notification the Commission has not informed BT or the trustee in writing to the contrary, the proposed purchaser shall be deemed to be acceptable to the Commission.
Condition No 5: (Veto rights)
A. BSkyB will vote in favour of any resolution of BiB to authorise its subsidiary which is responsible for promotional activities by means of marketing contributions for the subsidisation of set-top boxes ("McCo.") to provide marketing contributions or similar financial contributions in respect of sales of digital interactive set-top boxes where such resolution, where relevant including the proposed means of financing and any other consequent changes, has been recommended by the Chief Executive Officer of BiB and unanimously agreed to by the other BiB partners.
B. This condition will apply subject to the following criteria being met:
(i) the relevant digital set-top boxes are capable of receiving and running all of BiB's interactive services either in Open TV or reauthored format;
(ii) the operator(s) to whom it is proposed to provide marketing contributions or similar financial contributions in respect of sales of digital interactive set-top boxes have undertaken to make capacity available for BiB's interactive services for a period equivalent to that for which BiB has secured transponder capacity;
(iii) in the event that each of the three other BiB shareholders has a commercial interest in such a proposal (independently of their respective interest in BiB), BiB's auditors providing an opinion that the proposal is not, when taken as a whole, significantly less favourable than the provision of marketing contributions in respect of sales of BiB boxes set out in the BiB Business Plan. The auditor may take into account all factors which appear to the auditor to be relevant, including the balance of risk and reward to be derived from such proposal as compared to that to be derived from the provision of marketing contributions in respect of BiB boxes;
(iv) the proposal (a) does not require BSkyB to commit funding to BiB or McCo. in addition to that which it has already committed pursuant to the JVA; (b) is not funded through revenues which would otherwise be available for distribution to BSkyB as distributable profits; and (c) does not result in BSkyB losing joint control of BiB, in the event that the other shareholders commit additional funding to BiB and BSkyB does not; and
(v) the proposal does not reduce the funds contemplated as available within the agreed business plan for use as marketing contributions towards DTH digital interactive set-top boxes.
Condition No 6: (Conditional access and Simulcrypt)
A. BSkyB and Sky Subscribers Services Limited ("SSSL") confirm that SSSL will offer to develop and to operate Simulcrypt arrangements with all conditional access providers who administer access to non-SSSL digital television decoders in the United Kingdom. This offer to develop and operate Simulcrypt arrangements will remain open for the duration of the exemption.
B. SSSL will (and BSkyB will procure that it will) confirm in writing its offer to develop Simulcrypt arrangements within 21 days of a written request from a conditional access provider made in the required manner.
C. SSSL will (and BSkyB will procure that it will) use all reasonable endeavours to procure that Simulcrypt arrangements are operational within 12 months of the relevant request or within such other timescale as is agreed between the parties and to this end BSkyB and SSSL will cooperate fully with the conditional access provider (and its technology provider, if different).
D. In the event that BSkyB/SSSL is unable to meet these deadlines, a reasoned request for an extension must be submitted to OFTEL at least one month before the expiry of the deadline, which extension must be granted unless the inability to comply with such time frame is due primarily or exclusively to culpability on the part of BSkyB or SSSL. OFTEL will inform in writing the Commission of its reasons to accept or reject the request for the extension at least two weeks before adopting its decision. If the Commission does not object to OFTEL's proposal within a period of two weeks, it will be understood that the Commission accepts this proposal.
E. This condition is subject to:
(i) the conditional access provider who wishes to operate a Simulcrypt arrangement (and its technology provider, if different) cooperating fully with SSSL, and if appropriate, SSSL's technology provider, News Digital systems Limited (NDS), in developing a Simulcrypt arrangement between the NDS technology administered by SSSL and the conditional access system employed by the conditional access provider and agreeing fair and reasonable commercial terms for such development;
(ii) the conditional access provider agreeing with SSSL fair and reasonable commercial terms for ongoing arrangements relating to the operation of the Simulcrypt arrangement, including, without limitation, arrangements for the cross carriage of necessary data; and
(iii) the security of the conditional access provider's system not being compromised such that it creates a threat to the security of the system used by SSSL.
Condition No 7: (Subsidy recovery)
A. The BiB Parties confirm that McCo. will carry out its activities in the United Kingdom for the recovery of marketing contributions under arrangements with SSSL and, as relevant, other conditional access and access control providers each of which is, or will at the relevant time be, subject to the British regime.
B. The recovery of marketing contributions by McCo. shall be permitted provided that the following conditions shall apply:
(i) recovery in respect of marketing contributions will be made via:
(a) charges to customers for broadcast conditional access services (including BSkyB); and
(b) charges to customers for access control services (including BiB's subsidiary which carries out the business of an interactive service platform operator "Services Co.")and such charges will be made on a fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory basis;
(ii) the subsidy recovery element of any conditional access and access control charges will be based on a charge per card entitled (conditional access) or per authentication (access control) basis which may vary over time provided that:
(a) different charges may be made for different classes of conditional access and access control usage, so long as such differentiation does not distort, prevent or restrict competition within or between members of any of the following classes of purchasers of conditional access or access control services or between such classes: broadcasters, retailers of broadcast services, BiB Services Co. and its competitors, competitors to BiB Services Co. inter se, and any other class of purchasers of conditional access or access control services which may from time to time emerge;
(b) different options taking account of bulk purchases of conditional access and/or access control services may be offered on a non-discriminatory basis;
(iii) recovery will be made:
(a) in accordance with a scheme (or schemes) allocating recovery charges on an objective basis between customers for broadcast conditional access services and customers for access control services on each of which the Director-General for Telecommunications has:
- been consulted, and
- had prior notice of at least 30 days of the form of the scheme which is put into practice, and
- raised no objection to that form of scheme being put into practice
or
(b) as otherwise required by the Director-General for Telecommunications from time to time, or
(c) as determined in the resolution of any dispute:
- by a court of competent jurisdiction, or
- by a competent national authority, or
- by a procedure contemplated by Directive 95/47/EC or the British regime or any other relevant national legislation or regulation implementing the same or any relevant national legislation or regulation governing the provision of access control services, or
- under an appropriate and independent arbitration procedure which the BiB Parties will procure is made available to third parties.
C. Compliance with this condition shall be presumed where the BiB Parties have operated in accordance with the British regime.
D. References in this condition to the Director-General for Telecommunications shall be read as references to such regulator or regulatory body as from time to time is entrusted with the regulation of the British regime.
Condition No 8: (Provision of information by McCo.)
A. The BiB Parties shall procure that McCo. shall not in any way discriminate between BiB Services Co. and any other interested party in connection with:
(i) the dissemination of technical information within its responsibility;
(ii) the dissemination of changes to technical information within its responsibility which would affect the ability of interested parties to utilise the features of BiB for such purpose.
B. Where a company within the BiB Group receives a request in the required manner from an interested Party which is not within its responsibility but is within the responsibility of another party, it will provide within ten working days the name and address of each person whom it believes could supply such technical information and forward the request to such person or persons.
Condition No 9: (Provision of information by BSkyB)
BSkyB shall take the following steps in relation to the dissemination of technical information regarding the functional features of BiB boxes:
(a) within ten working days of the date or receipt of a request made in the required manner from an interested party, BSkyB or SSSL will make available to such interested party a non-disclosure agreement;
(b) within ten working days of the date of receipt in the required manner of a non-disclosure agreement executed by such interested party, BSkyB will make available to such interested party a list of technical information, which shall specify any item which requires the execution of a supplemental technical agreement, should such party wish to have access to it;
(c) within ten working days of the date of receipt of a request made in the required manner, BSkyB will make available copies of any item of technical information requested by any interested party who has received a list of technical information in accordance with the provision of paragraph (b) above. Where access to a particular item requires execution of a supplemental technical agreement, time shall run from the date of receipt in the required manner of the relevant executed supplemental technical agreement, which shall be made available to the interested party within ten working days of the relevant request;
(d) BSkyB will advise affected parties if the BiB box specification changes immediately after it advises manufacturers of BiB boxes;
(e) BSkyB will advise affected parties of any functional change:
(i) as regards the intention to introduce such functional change, immediately after completion of the technical specification and before testing together with an estimate of the time at which the change will be implemented;
(ii) as regards any alterations to the intentions and estimated timings referred to above, immediately after deciding to make such alterations;
provided that if any information falling within the first exclusion in the definition of functional change is information which will affect the ability of affected parties to deliver broadcast and/or interactive services through BiB boxes such information will be advised to them as soon as reasonably practicable;
(f) BSkyB shall procure that SSSL complies with the provisions of paragraphs (a) to (e) with regard to technical information within its sphere of responsibility;
(g) where BSkyB or any member of the BSkyB Group receives a request in the required manner from an interested party for technical information which is not within its responsibility, but is within the responsibility of another party, it will provide within ten working days the name and address of each person whom it believes could supply such technical information and forward the request to such person or persons.
Condition No 10: (Anti-avoidance)
A. The BiB parties will ensure that no other member of the BiB Group does anything which would, if carried out by McCo., be a breach of the requirements set out in Conditions Nos 2(A), 7 and 8 or which has the effect of avoiding the effect of any such requirement.
B. Breaches of the abovementioned requirements shall not be a breach of this condition unless they would have been a breach of a condition set out in any of Conditions Nos 2, 7 and 8.
