Article 2
This Decision is addressed to:
Scottish and Newcastle plc 50 East Fettes Avenue Edinburgh EH4 1RR United Kingdom.
Done at Brussels, 16 June 1999.
For the Commission
Karel VAN MIERT
Member of the Commission
(1) OJ 13, 21.2.1962, p. 204/62.
(2) OJ C 8, 13.1.1998, p. 4.
(3) On-licensed premises are those which are licensed to sell alcoholic beverages for consumption on and off the premises as opposed to off-licensed premises such as supermarkets which are licensed for off-premises consumption only.
(4) OJ L 173, 30.6.1983, p. 5.
(5) OJ L 214, 6.8.1997, p. 27.
(6) OJ 127, 20.8.1963, p. 2268/63.
(7) One barrel equals 1,63659 hl; 1 hl equals 0,611026 barrels.
(8) The UK Government extended the scope by also allowing for one bottle-conditioned beer from 1 April 1998.
(9) The Commission does not have precise information on the market shares of the other UK brewers. Nevertheless, it does not estimate that the HHI for all brewers would reach the 1800 mark as from which a market is considered to be "highly concentrated".
(10) Defined in the MMC Report as brewers which "have a business which is mainly, but not necessarily wholly, concentrated in a single region of the UK". The number of regionals in 1996 is defined taking the number of owned pubs and production volume for the smallest regional in the MMC Report as a benchmark.
(11) The licensing system is slightly different in Scotland.
(12) This is also sometimes called a guest beer, although the legal definition of a guest beer refers to the purchase of a cask-conditioned beer from another supplier (see recital 16).
(13) Except for a limited number of specified reasons, i.e. where the owner of the pub wants to use the outlet for his own purposes as a managed house, in which case the lessee receives compensation fixed by law, the parties can negotiate a new agreement. In the absence of a new agreement, the UK courts will renew the agreement on similar terms to the existing agreement with the exception of the rent and the duration which cannot exceed 14 years.
(14) Article 7(2).
(15) See also paragraph 51 of the Commission notice concerning Commission Regulations (EEC) No 1983/83 and (EEC) No 1984/83 of 22 June 1983 on the application of Article 81(3) of the Treaty to categories of exclusive distribution and exclusive purchasing arrangements (hereinafter: "the notice to the Regulation") (OJ C 101, 13.4.1984, p. 2).
(16) The accountant commented that S& N has no factual knowledge of its tenants. S& N informed the Commission that is has considerable factual knowledge of the turnover of its tenants (based on S& N's sales to tenants and tenants' price lists which are publicly displayed in accordance with UK legislation).
(17) In October 1993, S& N became a "national brewer" so that its tenants were entitled, pursuant to the Beer Orders, to the special rights described in recital 28.
(18) The accountant, on behalf of a complainant, provided a guide showing how he would construct a pub lease rent. However, the accountant provided no evidence that his model reflects the workings of the open market.
(19) Case 27/76, United Brands, [1978] ECR 207, paragraph 12.
(20) Case C-234/89, Stergios Delimitis v. Henninger Bräu, [1991] ECR I-935, at paragraph 16.
(21) The German (procedural language) version of the judgment uses the term 'Schankwirtschaften' In the French version, being the working language within the Court, the term 'cafés' is used.
(22) Extracts from Stats MR's survey of retail prices, submitted by a national brewer to the OFT.
(23) See footnote 20; at paragraph 17.
(24) See footnote 20; at paragraph 10.
(25) See also paragraph 13 of the Delimitis judgement: "If such (exclusive beer supply) agreements do not have the object of restricting competition within the meaning of Article 81(1), it is nevertheless necessary to ascertain whether they have the effect of preventing, restricting or distorting competition".
(26) Case 23/67, ECR 1967, p. 407
(27) See footnote 19; at paragraph 14.
(28) With regard to competition policy, the main parameters are what is called the "above the line" parameters: overall positioning of the brand (including pricing), general marketing policy (advertising concept, national advertising, promotions) as opposed to "below the line" which is more "point of sale"-related marketing.
(29) The intrinsic link between the loan tie and the actual volume purchased cannot be denied, the best evidence for this link is the inability of the brewers to dissociate the two in their internal accounts.
(30) This access could be excluded in practice by way of multiple non-exclusive loans.
(31) The exclusive supply agreement for the Inntrepreneur and Spring estates ended on 28 March 1998; that for the Allied Domecq estate on 12 December 1997.
(32) The average sales price of a private freehold UK pub is around GBP 200000. (Source: Fleurets).
(33) See also paragraph 22 of the Delimitis judgment. See footnote 20.
(34) Penultimate sentence of paragraph 1 of the operative part of the judgment.
(35) The Court of First Instance pointed out in Cases T-7 & 9/93, Langnese-Iglo and Schöller, [1995] ECR II-1539 and II-1611, paragraphs 129 and 95 respectively (hereinafter: "the German ice-cream cases") that "where there is a network of similar agreements concluded by the same producer, the assessment of the effects of that network on competition applies to all the individual agreements making up the network".
(36) Paragraph 40 of the notice to the Regulation (OJ C 121, 13.5.1992, p. 2). See footnote 15.
(37) Last sentence of paragraph 1 of the operative part of the judgment.
(38) See footnote 33; at paragraph 87 for Schöller and paragraph 112 for Langnese-Iglo.
(39) The Commission has no detailed information on S& N's tied network previous to 1990, i.e. for the period 1985 to 1990. It is, therefore, possible that in that period, S& N's tied network might not have been a significant contributor to the foreclosure. However, it will be assumed, possibly to the disadvantage of the company, that the leases fall within the scope of Article 81(1) for the whole period.
(40) See also paragraph 53 of the notice to the Regulation: see footnote 15.
(41) Commission Decision 90/186/EEC - Moosehead/Whitbread (OJ L 100, 20.4.1990, p. 32, at recital 16).
(42) Paragraph 41 of the notice to the Regulation. See footnote 15.
(43) In so far as the underlying agreements are in conformity with Article 81.
(44) See Article 14(c)(2) of the Regulation: "the application of less favourable prices or conditions for sale [...] without any objective justified reason".
(45) Article 14(c)(2) of the Regulation.
(46) This refers to the possibility under Article 6, read in conjunction with Article 7(1)(a) of the Regulation, whereby lessees can buy beer brands of a different type from those supplied under the agreement and can offer these to the consumers. This possibility is equally maintained by the standard leases, i.e. the procedure for the non-specified types.
(47) A different concept from "significant contribution to the foreclosure of the market".
(48) Case 26/76, Metro v. Commission, [1977] ECR 1875.
(49) Case 63/75, Fonderies Roubaix v. Société Nouvelle des Fonderies [1976] ECR 111, at paragraph 8.
